SEBI Proposes Major Overhaul of Gold and Silver ETF Valuation Methods
India's securities market regulator has introduced a comprehensive proposal to revolutionize how gold and silver Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs) determine their underlying asset values. The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has released a consultation paper suggesting a fundamental shift from international pricing mechanisms to domestic market-based valuation systems.
Current Valuation System and Its Challenges
The existing framework for gold and silver ETF valuation relies heavily on international benchmarks, specifically the London Bullion Market Association (LBMA) price denominated in US dollars. This international price undergoes multiple conversion processes to reflect Indian market conditions, including currency conversion to Indian rupees and various adjustments for customs duties, local taxes, and market premiums or discounts.
This multi-layered approach has created significant inconsistencies across the mutual fund industry. Different asset management companies (AMCs) currently have the discretion to use varying sources and frequencies for price adjustments, resulting in non-uniform valuation practices across gold and silver ETFs in India.
Proposed Domestic Benchmark System
SEBI's new proposal advocates for a streamlined approach using domestic spot prices published by Indian commodity exchanges, particularly the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX). These prices are derived through daily polling of a diverse panel of domestic market participants, including importers, traders, and jewellers, providing a more accurate reflection of real-time supply and demand conditions within India.
The regulatory body emphasizes that commodity exchanges conduct daily spot price polling, and these prices serve as reference points for physical market transactions in gold and silver within the domestic market. This approach aims to eliminate the complexity and inconsistencies inherent in the current international pricing system.
Industry Response and Concerns
The proposal has generated mixed reactions from industry stakeholders. Surendra Mehta, national secretary at the India Bullion and Jewellers Association (IBJA), has expressed significant reservations about the suggested changes. His primary concern centers on the timing limitations of domestic price polling.
Commodity exchange spot prices are declared only once daily at 4:30 PM, which Mehta argues creates a substantial disconnect from the global gold and silver markets that operate continuously for 23 hours each day. This timing mismatch could potentially lead to significant gaps between international and domestic spot prices.
Alternative Valuation Suggestions
Industry representatives have proposed alternative approaches to address valuation concerns. Mehta suggests that since the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) utilizes IBJA prices for Sovereign Gold Bond (SGB) issuance, redemption, and lending against jewellery, the same pricing mechanism could be adopted for ETF valuation purposes.
This suggestion highlights the broader debate about whether India's precious metals ETF industry should maintain its connection to international markets or embrace a more domestically-focused approach to pricing and valuation.
Regulatory Timeline and Public Consultation
SEBI has opened the consultation paper for public comments until August 6, 2025, providing stakeholders with an opportunity to share their perspectives on the proposed changes. This consultation period allows various market participants, including AMCs, commodity exchanges, bullion associations, and investors, to provide feedback on the practical implications of the proposed valuation methodology.
The regulatory body's initiative reflects its ongoing efforts to standardize practices across the mutual fund industry and reduce discrepancies that may confuse investors or create unfair advantages for certain market participants.
Implications for Investors and Market Participants
The proposed changes could have far-reaching consequences for gold and silver ETF investors. A shift to domestic pricing mechanisms may result in more consistent valuation practices across different fund houses, potentially reducing confusion and improving transparency for retail investors.
However, the transition may also introduce new challenges. Domestic pricing systems might not always accurately reflect global precious metals market movements, particularly during periods of high international volatility or significant currency fluctuations.
For asset management companies, the standardization could simplify operational processes by eliminating the need for complex international price adjustments. However, it may also require significant changes to existing systems and processes for calculating net asset values.
Market Impact and Future Considerations
The precious metals ETF market in India has grown substantially in recent years, driven by increased investor interest in gold and silver as portfolio diversification tools. Any changes to valuation methodologies will likely influence investor behavior and market dynamics in this segment.
The success of SEBI's proposed changes will largely depend on the reliability and frequency of domestic price discovery mechanisms. Ensuring that Indian commodity exchanges can provide accurate, timely, and comprehensive price information will be crucial for the proposal's effectiveness.
As the consultation period progresses, market participants will need to carefully evaluate how these changes might affect their investment strategies and operational frameworks. The ultimate decision will shape the future landscape of precious metals investing in India's capital markets.
Disclaimer: The views and investment tips expressed in this article are for informational purposes only and do not represent financial advice. The views expressed are those of the sources cited and not necessarily those of this website or its management. Investing in equities or other financial instruments carries the risk of financial loss. Readers must exercise due caution and conduct their own research before making any investment decisions. We are not liable for any losses incurred as a result of decisions made based on this article. Please consult a qualified financial advisor before making any investment.
